A boy on horseback came over the top of Midnight Creek one day around 1904 and looked down on four Indians digging camas in a little meadow below him. One of them called out “good hunting” as he passed. Thirty-three years later, William J. Mullen of Pocatello put that moment at the head of a letter protesting an elk hunt, and the Pocatello Tribune gave it room in its Buzz of the Burg column on Tuesday, September 14, 1937.
Mullen had written to the columnist, Ing, two days earlier, on Sunday, September 12. Most of his letter dealt with Pocatello’s watershed and its elk herd. But it begins on the high ground above Arbon Valley, and it offers one of the few pictures this site has found of that country as a man remembered it before the sheep came.
Aspen, grass and clear water
Midnight Creek and Rattlesnake Creek both rise from the springs of the high basin at Crystal and run down to Bannock Creek, which carries their water north through the Fort Hall Reservation. The head of Midnight Creek sits against the divide that separates the valley from the Gibson Jack and Mink Creek country behind Pocatello. There was enough settlement along it by 1915 for the American Falls Press to report R. O. Stewart teaching school “on Midnight creek, in the Crystal district.”
Mullen did not give a year for his first ride, only the count of thirty-three years. If he was the Bill Mullen born in 1888, he would have been about sixteen. He went back to that country often in the years that followed, and the place he described was one of aspen groves, good grass and clean streams. Deer that wintered lower down climbed through it every spring by way of Midnight Creek, headed for the basin drained by Gibson Jack and Mink creeks. As he remembered it, no sheep had grazed there yet and no one had been cutting the timber.
On a visit many years afterward, at a time he did not name, he found the camas meadow beaten down to “a dust bed.” He blamed the sheep. The whole range, he wrote, had been grazed far too hard. The ferns and grass had been trampled out, the aspen roots stood exposed, and the ruffed grouse had left. Where exactly the meadow lay, and who the four diggers were, his letter does not say.
A range too small to share
The state had announced the hunt a month before. On August 16 the Tribune reported that the state game warden meant to hold emergency hunts wherever winter feed looked short, including one in October to take 100 elk from the Cache National Forest in Bannock, Franklin, Bear Lake and Oneida counties. The forest around Pocatello was then a district of the Cache, and Mullen’s letter names the same figure of 100 elk, so this was very probably the hunt he was fighting, though he never says which ground he meant. The pages read for this post do not tell how the October hunt turned out.
Mullen traced the forest reserve itself back to his own boyhood, when the town held a protest meeting on Gibson Jack Creek after word got around that sheep were on the watershed feeding Pocatello’s water supply. Keeping livestock away from that water, he said, had been the reason for the reserve in the first place.
He granted that the feed might well be short. His complaint was that so small a range had been grazed so heavily it could no longer carry a modest elk herd through a winter. He asked how long the sheep had been running there. He wanted all the land between Midnight, Mink and Michaud creeks, clear down to the Portneuf River, closed to public grazing, and he thought the sheepmen could stand the loss. He also opposed pushing a road up every canyon, adding that he had considered the need for fire protection before taking that stand.
People in Pocatello, he argued, had inherited wild country lying less than an hour from Center Street, and sheep, hunters and woodcutters had no right to ruin it. He ended by doubting that 100 elk needed killing at all, and wondering where the town would find 100 hunters willing to do it.
Sheep on the divide
The papers answer part of his question about the sheep. In June 1913 the Tribune reported that 120 settlers and homesteaders “just over the Mink creek divide in Oneida county,” on the valley side, had sent a protest to the district forester at Ogden. Sheep had been let onto the West Fork of Mink Creek and then onto the south slope of the divide, and the settlers wanted that range for their own cattle and horses and worried about their water. The same month, Pocatello’s city council took up a petition against the stock lease on the part of the reserve that drains into Bannock Creek, and heard that sheep had always used the range there. That sits poorly with Mullen’s memory of country no sheep had touched, though the two accounts may concern different ground. By 1933 the Tribune was describing a sheep range between Elk Meadows and Midnight Creek, where a sheepman killed three cougars that August.
The sheep were an old quarrel on the Arbon side as well, where farmers kept bands out of their canyons in 1920. The elk had a history on the divide too. The Pocatello herd started from elk shipped in from Yellowstone Park in 1916 and 1917, and by 1933 its game preserve covered the heads of Crystal, Midnight, Gibson Jack and City creeks. Valley farmers came to know those animals well, as told in the state’s elk at Crystal. Other pages on this site follow the same high country through Crystal in the winter of 1923–24 and the mail road over Mink Creek.
The man who planted the herd
The letter-writer was almost certainly William Joseph “Bill” Mullen, profiled by the Idaho State Journal in 1965. In 1925 the Tribune had listed a William J. Mullen among the sons of Mrs. J. B. Mullen. A son of John B. and Katherine English Mullen, Bill was born in Pocatello on February 17, 1888. He started with the railroad as a brakeman in 1908 and stayed for 49 years.
The profile credits him with helping L. A. “Dutch” Lehrbas plant what it calls the first elk near Pocatello, in 1917. The 1933 Tribune dates the first shipment to April 1916 and a second to April 1917. As a young man he and a group of friends built a cabin on Midnight Creek and kept it stocked, and he was still making trips up to it in later years. The profile says nothing of the 1937 letter. If it has him right, the man who wrote to spare 100 elk had helped bring their forebears to those hills twenty years before.
Sources
- Pocatello Tribune, September 14, 1937, page 5
- Pocatello Tribune, August 16, 1937, page 1
- American Falls Press, December 23, 1915, page 6
- Pocatello Tribune, June 6, 1913, page 4
- Semi-Weekly Pocatello Tribune, June 18, 1913, page 4
- Pocatello Tribune, August 15, 1933, page 5
- Pocatello Tribune, September 6, 1933, page 8
- Pocatello Tribune, September 2, 1925, page 6
- Idaho State Journal, May 16, 1965, page 13
- Idaho State Journal, June 14, 1968, page 18