When the Salt Lake Tribune went to press on January 23, 1900, the settlers of Bannock Valley had a reservation for a neighbor. The north end of what is now Arbon Valley, then part of Oneida County, ran up against the Fort Hall Reservation, and a bill to shrink that reservation had just cleared the United States Senate.
The bill, Senator Shoup’s, would ratify the agreement the Bannock and Shoshone people had made with the government in February 1898. It had passed the Senate twice before and died both times in the House, where eastern members had seen in it, as the Tribune put it, “an attempt to rob the Indian of his heritage.” The paper’s long article, printed with a map of the proposed cession, set out to prove them wrong.
“Decidedly the best of it”
By the Tribune’s count, the Tribes were giving up nearly a third of the land the Fort Bridger treaty of 1868 had reserved to them. The acting agent had certified that those who signed made up a majority of the reservation’s grown men. Of the purchase money, $75,000 would build a modern school at Ross Fork, and the Tribes would be paid the balance year by year. The article could not settle on the total, giving it as $600,000 in one paragraph and $500,000 in another. Any tribal member already living on the ceded ground could stay on the land he had settled, or choose land inside the smaller reservation and move or sell what he had built.
The writer was making a case, and he made it in the condescending manner of his day. Most of the cession, he said, was mountain and lava, with perhaps 50,000 acres that would ever grow a crop. The Tribes, meanwhile, would keep the rich bottom lands, Bannock Creek’s valley among them, where many Bannocks were farming with implements the government had given them. That passage is too damaged in the scan to quote. His conclusion, though, came through whole. The Indians, he wrote, had “obtained decidedly the best of it”:
They receive a handsome sum for the lands that are useless to them, the arid hills and plains where their forefathers hunted the jack rabbit and the lava stretches where they carved the obsidian arrow heads and spear points. And they retain for their own the rich and picturesque bottom lands of the Snake, the fertile Bannock valley, the rich stretches lying south of the Blackfoot...
The “Bannock valley” he meant was most likely the reservation’s share of it, the lower reaches of Bannock Creek below the settlers’ farms. In 1907 the decree in United States v. Daniels would split the creek’s water between the Tribes downstream and the settlers upstream. The article closed on a joke in mock dialect about a Bannock man and a settler’s missing horse, which is left in the transcription below and not retold here.
Crystal opens
Congress approved the agreement on June 6, 1900. Two years later, Proclamation 472, signed May 7, 1902, threw the ceded land open to settlement at noon on June 17. A settler could claim up to 160 acres under the homestead, townsite, stone and timber, or mining laws, and pay for it besides, at $2.50 an acre for farm land and $1.25 for grazing land. A fifth was due at entry and the balance at final proof, the point where a settler showed he had met the law’s terms and proved up. Every Indian living on the ceded land who wanted an allotment, the proclamation said, had already been given one.
The cession’s line started at the southwest corner of township 9 south, range 34 east, on the reservation’s south boundary, and ran north. That corner took in the Crystal basin, where the first Crystal homesteads were entered on October 2, 1902, and where the community traced in Crystal grew up. West of the line, the lower Bannock Creek country most likely stayed reservation land. The line would move again in the later 1930s, when the government bought the West Fork farms, as Pauline and West Fork tells.
Butter by sleigh and wagon
The neighbors met on the road, too. On January 26, 1904, the Tribune’s “Intermountain Nuggets” column picked up a paragraph from the American Falls Advertiser, offering it as proof of the “brotherly spirit” between whites and Indians around American Falls:
Bishop Bowen of Arbon was down Wednesday with butter. There is a heavy fall of snow in the mountains, and the bishop came as far as the reservation in a sleigh. The sleighing gave out there and he had to borrow a wagon from an Indian farmer in order to complete the trip.
“Down” most likely meant down to American Falls, where the Advertiser was printed. The churchman was probably D. J. Bowen, who had led the Arbon Branch of the Latter-day Saint church since it was organized in 1900, as the first congregation entry tells. Strictly speaking Arbon had no bishop until it became a ward in 1908, the subject of the first bishop. The paragraph gives no name for the farmer who lent the wagon, nor where he lived. The Advertiser itself has not turned up, so which Wednesday it was, likely one in January 1904, cannot be pinned down.
The Tribes’ side
The papers of 1900 and 1904 spoke for the settlers. More than a century later the Sho-Ban News, which covers the reservation, told the story from the Tribes’ side while reporting on a land case. Tribal attorney Bill Bacon told the paper in September 2025 that federal officials had come to the Tribes in 1898 to talk about ceding land back to the United States, and that the agreement the Tribes signed became the 1900 Act. Under the Act the ceded land could go out in three ways: under the homestead, townsite and mining laws, at no more than 160 acres to a person, or at public auction. A 2024 report in the paper gave the cession as 416,000 acres.
The Act has not gone quiet. In 2023 a federal district court held that a land swap proposed between the Bureau of Land Management and the J. R. Simplot Company near Pocatello broke the 1900 Act and the government’s trust duty to the Tribes in the ceded lands. A Ninth Circuit panel upheld that ruling in August 2025. After the appeals court heard the case in November 2024, Fort Hall Business Council Chairman Lee Juan Tendoy said the Tribes would protect those lands. “The ceded lands,” he said, “are still a part of our Treaty language.”
The original article
Salt Lake Tribune, January 23, 1900, page 3. Transcribed from the library’s OCR text of the page; the page scan was not available here, so the punctuation and paragraph breaks are supplied, and the map printed with the article is left out.
THE POCATELLO LAND BILL
Provisions of the Measure that Senator Shoup Has Succeeded in Having the Senate Pass.
The passage by the United States Senate on Friday last of Senator Shoup’s bill to ratify the treaty with the Bannock and Shoshone Indians, concluded February [illegible], 1898, does not, as may be supposed by many of the uninformed, comprehend the restoration to the public domain of the entire Fort Hall Indian reservation. Nor does the courteous treatment by the Senate of the extremely modest measure indicate anything as to the action of the House, for twice previously has the bill, practically in its present form, passed the higher legislative body only to be killed in the House. Each time it has come up for debate it has been strangled by the sickly sentimentality of the far East, whose Representatives saw in it an attempt to rob the Indian of his heritage, though of the two parties to the treaty the Indians get decidedly the best of the bargain, as will be shown by its analysis and its contemplated [illegible] is the hope of the Indians as well as of a few white men that the bill will pass the House during the present term, but the treatment it has previously received does not augur too favorably for a warm reception now.
Under the act of June [illegible] the Secretary of the Interior appointed as United States Indian Commissioners Benjamin F. Barge, John H. McNeely and Charles G. Hoyt, and under this act the commissioners were authorized to negotiate with the Bannock and Shoshone Indians for cession to the United States of part of their surplus lands. Under this authority the treaty of cession of nearly one-third of the lands given to the Indians by the Fort Bridger treaty of July 3, 1868, was concluded, Jim [illegible], better known as Maj. Jim Pocatello, Tom [illegible] Johnson and [illegible] other male Indians over 18 years of age and representing both tribes signing the agreement. At that time F. G. Irwin Jr., of the army and acting as Indian agent, certified that 227 constituted a majority of the male adult Indians of the reserve, so that the acceptance by 250 selected to act for the two tribes constituted a clear majority. The lands so ceded embrace about 300,000 acres, and of the least desirable portion of the reservation, as will be shown, and as consideration the Indians are to receive $600,000, $75,000 of which is to be expended in the erection of a modern school plant at Ross Fork and for educational [illegible], the remainder to be paid in eight annual payments of $50,000 each and one of [illegible]. In addition the deferred payments are to bear interest at [illegible] per cent, and the entire sum is to be exempted from payment of any claims for depredations, etc. Further, the Indians will have the privilege of retaining any lands they have settled upon within the limits of the proposed cession, or, choosing to select other lands within the reduced reservation, may remove or sell their improvements on the lands they vacate.
Of the proposed cession it is doubtful if there are altogether 50,000 acres of arable land. The bulk of it is mountain and lava fields, and a study of the above map shows that the Portneuf is the only waterway within its limits. This, while a considerable stream, flows for the most part through narrow canyons and making but narrow strips along its banks that might be cultivated. All of the unsurveyed lands shown on the map in the proposed cession are mountains, as are also fully two-thirds of the surveyed portion. The most considerable area of land capable of cultivation within the proposed cession is in townships 5 and 6, range [illegible] east, where the valley of the Portneuf widens out from Pocatello to the north. Here approximately 22,000 acres of gently sloping bench land, covered with a luxuriant growth of sagebrush, is capable of being brought under a state of high cultivation, and sufficient water for the entire area can be brought from Ross Fork creek, shown to the north on the map.
But even here the enterprising settler will be conscious of the irony of the situation and of the absurdity of the expressed fears that the Indians are being robbed. He will stand at the angle of the northwest boundary of the cession, which happens also to be the northwest boundary of the sage covered desert, and will look down with hungered eyes on the magnificent bottom lands of the Portneuf, Ross Fork creek and twenty other great tributaries of the great Snake river. To the north and west he will gaze on [illegible] hundreds of square miles of fertile grassy plains and meadows, enriched with the depositions of ages from the many rivers. Lands that under the beneficent dominion of the white man would become a domain fit to rival the valleys of the Nile in productiveness. But these are not for him or his race. They are to be retained for the Indians, who also receive $500,000 for the giving up of some lava stretches which they do not want. Here is a new version of the white man’s burden. He must reclaim the desert and make glad the waste places, but where nature has [illegible] moods, here must a home be reserved for the Indian, and the Government will give him [illegible] mowing [illegible] to cut the hay to sell to the Government. A condition equally happy for the Indians exists to the [illegible] of the Bannock Range, where the [illegible] broad and fertile valley of Bannock creek is [illegible] to them. Many of the Bannocks are here engaged in the cultivation of [illegible] their implements being gifts, and they are becoming good [illegible] well as in the accepted meaning of the [illegible].
It may be stated here, too, that since the establishment of the railroad town of Pocatello in the center of the reservation there has been a marked improvement among the Indians, which must be attributed to their association with the whites.
Of the lands within the proposed cession, aside from the possible 50,000 acres of arable land, the mountains and low rolling hills will afford excellent and extensive cattle ranges. There are also extensive forests of cedar which have attained a good growth, and in the higher parts of the range there is an unimportant growth of the pines. Of the mineral possibilities of the area comparatively little is known, the jealousy with which the Indians have guarded against anything like an intelligent prospecting of the region having discouraged all but the most surreptitious efforts in that direction. One strong copper ledge, however, too prominent to be left unnoticed, crops out in the mountains east of Pocatello and has been traced on the surface for five miles, and in this section some remarkably handsome specimens of azurite have been picked up. Gold and silver are also in evidence, but to what extent they may be found cannot be guessed at until prospectors may work without molestation. Perhaps the mineral industry that will be the earliest [illegible] upon will be the quarrying of a very superior building stone. There are some reefs of red sandstone to be found, but the prized article is a white sandstone, which is found in extensive beds and is hardly yet metamorphosed, being somewhat soft and easy to work but hardening with exposure. Under special permission from the Indians enough of this stone to construct several handsome business blocks in Pocatello has been quarried, and its dressing and exportation is expected to develop into a considerable industry after the treaty is ratified.
From the above it will be seen that in the treaty made two years ago the Indians obtained decidedly the best of it. They receive a handsome sum for the lands that are useless to them, the arid hills and plains where their forefathers hunted the jack rabbit and the lava stretches where they carved the obsidian arrow heads and spear points. And they retain for their own the rich and picturesque bottom lands of the Snake, the fertile Bannock valley, the rich stretches lying south of the Blackfoot and, perhaps dearest of all to the Indian heart, the great mountain masses that are piled against and around the lofty Mount Putnam, where the bear, the moose, the elk and the deer abound, a total area of 900,000 acres of as choice a region as the sun ever shone on.
Trust these Bannocks and Shoshones to make a good bargain for themselves in any kind of a transaction, as the following will show:
A settler at Warm Creek had lost one of his horses and surmised that it had strayed to the reservation. Meeting a Bannock Indian on horseback, the following conversation took place:
“You seen my horse, Jim?”
“Yes, me see um. Got white face?”
“Yes.”
“Yes, me see um. Got tree white foot?”
“Yes, yes.”
“Yes, me see um. Got roached mane?”
“Yes.”
“Yes, me see um. Got glass eye?”
“Yes, yes. Where is he, Jim?”
“Yes, me no see um.”
“Hold on here!” the settler cried, as the Indian started to ride away. “Here, here’s half a dollar.”
“Ugh! Half dollah, me no see um; ketch tree dollah, um me see um; five dollah, me [illegible]