No one came to argue. On the afternoon of Saturday, July 27, 1918, the Power County commissioners sat at the courthouse in American Falls to hear any objection to a herd district asked for by the people of Arbon Valley. None was filed, and before the meeting was over a broad part of the valley had become ground where stock could no longer roam at will.
The American Falls Press followed every step of it in its printed proceedings of the county board.
Fencing the cattle in
Under the ordinary rule, as a court decision quoted in this site’s 2012 letters on the Arbon Herd District explains, it fell to the landowner to fence his neighbors’ animals out. A herd district reversed the burden. A notice for a different Power County district, set for hearing in January 1916, put it plainly: within its lines, “it will be unlawful for horses, mules, asses, cattle, swine, sheep and goats to run at large.”
Farmers had wanted that protection for years. In August 1909 the Press told in its American Falls local news of a Sunday morning surprise:
J. R. Clark found about forty head of range cattle in his grain field Sunday morning. They vaulted the fence with the ease and grace of a deer, and unceremoniously departed for the desert when discovered. They did a great deal of damage.
“The herd law is a necessity,” the editor added. Power County granted its Herd District No. 1 in April 1913, during the county’s first year, and one farming neighborhood after another sent in its own petition. Not every one succeeded. In July 1915 the board threw one out after opponents filed a remonstrance carrying “almost as many signers as the petition.”
Two weeks of waiting
The board opened its quarterly session on July 8, 1918, and that day rejected a herd petition that had been advertised for hearing. It found an error in the papers and judged that the land described “is not satisfactory to the residents of said district.” That one was likely not Arbon’s. The petition due for hearing on July 8 had been filed by James E. Ogden and others, and a year earlier a James Ogden had asked for Rockland valley land to be added to a herd district.
Arbon’s turn came on July 9. Only two commissioners sat that day: the chairman, Walter S. Sparks, and G. A. Brahmstadt, who represented Arbon Valley on the board. The minutes record the reading of “a petition of the residents of Arbon valley” for a herd district “in certain territory in Arbon valley,” and a hearing was fixed for July 27. Paul Bulfinch, the county clerk, gave public notice that “a hearing will be had on the merits of a proposed herd district within Arbon valley,” at two o’clock that Saturday afternoon at the courthouse.
On July 22 Sparks called the board back to order from its recess, but he sat alone, and the meeting was carried over to the 27th. The Press set the heading of that day’s minutes as July 22, 1919, a slip for 1918.
On the 27th all three commissioners were in their chairs. They passed the year’s real estate assessment roll as the assessor had turned it in, and then took up the valley’s request. With no remonstrance before them, they declared the territory a herd district “as prayed for in the petition.” A short item in the Press of July 30 reported, “There was no remonstrance to the petition.” The full minutes ran on September 10.
Pauline to Green Top
The order covered every section of township 10 south, range 33 east, along with a strip of sections down the west side of the township beyond it: sections 3 to 10, 16 to 20 and 29 to 32 of township 10 south, range 34 east. It named land in township 11 south as well, though that part of the description cannot be read with confidence on the surviving page.
Township 10 south, range 33 east is perhaps best imagined as the reach of Bannock Creek from Pauline up to the Central school, known as Green Top. The county’s voter-registration notice that spring split it between the Pauline and Arbon precincts. Inside it lay the Swim, Butler and Johnson homesteads, two and a half to three miles south of Pauline, whose history is told on the Swim family page. More on that end of the valley is on the Pauline and West Fork page.
Before adjourning, the board also picked the valley’s judges of election for the coming two years. Arbon precinct got T. B. Evans, Joe Arbon and James Payne; Pauline had E. C. England, W. E. Dawson and J. E. Kowallis; and Crystal had J. C. Davis, J. W. Staley and R. Butterfield. The Evans family and the Arbon family have pages of their own.
The minutes leave a good deal unsaid. They give no names of petitioners, do not say which animals the Arbon district shut out, and offer no hint of what moved the valley to ask. The Arbon news columns of June through August 1918 do not mention it at all.
Ninety years on
The district came back into view in 2012, when this site printed letters from the Power County prosecuting attorney about the Arbon Herd District, in April, July and August. They dealt with its taxes, its unfenced boundary and cattle drifting in off federal land, and treated it as a district that predated Idaho’s 1963 change in herd-district law. They give no date for its founding. Whether it is the same district the commissioners made in 1918 the old papers cannot say, but that July afternoon’s order is the earliest record of an Arbon Valley herd district they hold.
The original article
American Falls Press, September 10, 1918, page 2. Transcribed from the page scan.
COMMISSIONERS’ PROCEEDINGS.
American Falls, July 22nd, 1919.
On this day W. S. Sparks, chairman of the board of county commissioners called a commissioners’ meeting pursuant to recess taken July 9th, but no other members of the board being present a recess of said meeting was called until July 27th, and the board of equalization meeting was held open until the above date.
American Falls, Idaho, July 27th, 1918.
The board of county commissioners of Power county met this day as a board of equalization, and also in regular quarterly session pursuant to a recess taken July 22nd. All members of the board being present the following proceedings were had to-wit:
1918 real estate assessment roll having been examined, and no reductions or additions having been made it is ordered that said roll be approved as turned over by the county assessor, and that the board of equalization adjourn.
The board of county commissioners took up the matter of the herd petition in Arbon valley, as set for this day, and no remonstrance having been presented do hereby create the following district into a herd district as prayed for in the petition, to-wit: Said herd district to comprise all of township 10 south, range 33 E. B. M. and township 11 south, range 33 E. B. M., also sections 3 to 10 and 16 to 20, and 29 to 32 inclusive, township 10 south of range 34 E. B. M. Also sections 5 to 8 and 17 to 20 and 29 to 32 inclusive in township 11 south, range 34 E. B. M.
It appearing to the board that a party in interest in one of the tax foreclosure cases, namely L. R. Knifong property, brought by this county, wishes to redeem the property from said foreclosure, it is ordered that the $25.00 attorney fee authorized [illegible] for tax due and interest, and the abstract fee be accepted.
The following bills were allowed, and warrants ordered drawn on the current expense fund:
Power County Farm Bureau $49.61
Rufus Moore, witness certificate 6.00
In the matter of setting the salary of the prosecuting attorney of this county for the ensuing two years, which should be taken up at this time, it is ordered that the salary be set at $760.00 per annum.
It appearing to the board that T. C. Elgin, registrar of Bonanza Bar precinct has left the said precinct, it is ordered that Mrs. Josephine Oliver be appointed as registrar of said Bonanza Bar precinct.
The Judges of election for the ensuing two years were named as follows:
Fairview precinct—[illegible], E. [illegible] Geesey, J. C. [illegible].
Cedar Creek precinct—Wm. Jasmann, A. A. Friesen, Bert Evans.
Prosperity precinct—Chris Schrenk, Geo. L. Sprattler, Fred Colfelt.
Pleasant Valley precinct—Louis Adolf, C. F. Eggers, [illegible].
Lake precinct—Claude Drake, Chas. Hughes, F. A. Ziek.
Bonanza Bar precinct—Josephine Oliver, A. [illegible] Anderson, Wm. W. Campbell.
Little Creek precinct—Arthur [illegible], Mrs. Martin Gain, Ross McCarty.
Rockland precinct—S. N. Morris, Will Fifield, T. J. Lawson.
Rockland precinct—W. [illegible] Milke, [illegible] Gebhart, O. O. Ogden.
Landing—James Hartley, H. B. Currier, Wm. Groom.
Roy precinct—[illegible] J. Peterson, J. D. Lower, Bert Brown.
Arbon precinct—T. B. Evans, Joe Arbon, James Payne.
Pauline precinct—E. C. England, W. E. Dawson, J. E. Kowallis.
Crystal precinct—J. C. Davis, J. W. Staley, R. Butterfield.
Igo precinct—F. L. Cunningham, Paul Sparks, Ed. Quinlan.
Neeley precinct—Wm. Morgan, A. W. Isaac, H. C. Jones.
American Falls precinct—Lee Cummins, Mrs. Rowberry, T. E. St. John.
American Falls precinct—Stanley Matthews, W. W. Wall, Wm. Hanson.
It appearing to the board that O. F. Crowley, assessor, has used a great deal of diligence in collecting the personal property taxes due the county, and it appearing that he has been unable to collect some of the taxes on account of parties moving out of the country and various other reasons, it is ordered that the assessor be credited with a rebate of $[illegible] on the 1915 personal property roll, and $423.89 on the 1916 personal property roll with the understanding that the assessor file a list of the parties who are delinquent on said taxes in the amounts they are delinquent, with the county recorder with the express understanding that if he collect said amounts the money shall be turned into the county treasury, and that he use any means within the law in collecting said accounts, and start any proceedings necessary thereto.
Whereupon, no other business appearing before the board the meeting adjourned.
W. S. SPARKS, Chairman.
PAUL BULFINCH, Clerk.
Sources
- American Falls Press, August 7, 1909, page 4
- American Falls Press, May 22, 1913, page 2
- American Falls Press, July 29, 1915, page 4
- American Falls Press, January 6, 1916, page 2
- American Falls Press, October 19, 1917, page 8
- American Falls Press, May 10, 1918, page 6
- American Falls Press, June 25, 1918, page 3
- American Falls Press, July 12, 1918, page 3
- American Falls Press, July 16, 1918, page 2
- American Falls Press, July 30, 1918, page 1
- American Falls Press, July 30, 1918, page 4
- American Falls Press, September 10, 1918, page 2
- Swim family history, on this site
- ArbonValley.com, April 13, 2012, “Arbon Valley Herd District”
- ArbonValley.com, July 18, 2012, “Arbon Herd District”
- ArbonValley.com, August 27, 2012, “Herd District Clarifictations”
