The news that a corner of Arbon Valley now belonged to the federal government took up a single paragraph. On Tuesday, November 12, 1935, the Pocatello Tribune ran it among the short state items in “Here We Have Idaho,” a column signed by The Consul, in which each bit of news got a line of comment underneath. About 2,000 acres in the valley, the column said, had been bought by the United States as an addition to the Fort Hall Reservation.
The land lay in Power County, along the reservation’s southern edge, where the boundary cuts across the north end of the valley. Owners had been paid from $10 to $40 an acre, $16,834.56 in all, and every acre was to go into the reservation. More such purchases were being arranged in Bannock and Bingham counties. The column offered no reason for any of it. The Consul’s whole remark was a short question asking what a bigger reservation was for.
Brief as it was, the item did something nothing else had. The family pages on this site already described the federal land buying of the later 1930s and guessed that the Price, Fink and Lusk tracts were probably part of it, but until this paragraph turned up, no list of sellers printed at the time had been found. The paper named seven: Asael P. Condit, Alfred Bollingbroke, Ephraim Gooch, John Bischoff, Thos. D. Price, J. N. Ireland & Co., and Amelia D. Lewis.
The sellers
Several of those names belong to the north end of the valley. “Alfred Bollingbroke” was very probably Alfred Bolingbroke, a son of Charles and Maggie Bolingbroke. Charles had homesteaded on Bannock Creek a little north of the Pauline school, and Alfred farmed the home place with his brothers Edward and Guy. The 1917 draft list carried him as “Alford Bolingbroke, Pauline,” and when his mother died in 1943, her obituary still counted him among her sons at Arbon. Which of the family’s land he sold in 1935 is not known, and the Bolingbrokes kept farming in the valley for decades afterward, as the Bolingbroke family page tells.
John Bischoff had lived at Pauline since about 1908. When a Latter-day Saint Sunday school was organized there in 1910 he was among its assistants, a story told in Pauline and the Meadow Ward, and in 1913 he got his patent for a quarter section near Pauline. That homestead sits outside the present reservation, so his 1935 sale may have been of some other tract, or of ground alongside the reservation rather than within it. The paper is silent on the point.
The Thos. D. Price on the list was probably the Thomas D. Price who took out patents on the West Fork side in 1913, 1914 and 1924, in the Big Meadows country where Jennett Daniels Price and her Daniels brothers had homesteaded. He was probably her son. Asael P. Condit was probably the man granted a 643-acre stock-raising homestead west of Pauline in 1940, though where his 1935 land lay is unknown.
Ephraim Gooch does not appear in any of the valley records read for this site. A Gooch family settled on a homestead near Dry Canyon in 1917, and Belton Gooch and H. Edmund Gooch received patents in 1919 and 1922 in the survey township around Pauline, T10S R33E, but there is nothing to tie Ephraim to them. J. N. Ireland & Co. was a bank; Power County court notices of 1924 and 1925 call it “J. N. Ireland Company, Bankers, a corporation.” Why a bank held valley land to sell goes unexplained. Amelia D. Lewis has not been identified.
A protest over taxes
The paper came back to the purchase the next morning, this time at the top of its editorial page, under the heading “Tax Exempt Government Schemes.” The editorial called the price roughly $17,000 and noted that the government wanted still more land around the reservation’s borders. Its writer admitted not knowing the government’s purpose and took his stand on other ground: money. The United States paid no local taxes, so the state, the county, the school district and every other taxing body would lose whatever those acres had been bringing in.
To the editorial writer, Arbon Valley was one small example of a New Deal habit. He listed taxpaying land drowned by the Tennessee Valley Authority, a plan to settle 700 New Jersey families in a new town that would pay no taxes, and the federal housing and resettlement programs. The bill for all of it, he argued, fell on the people still on the tax rolls, who could carry no more, while county and town governments were left weaker. He ended by daring his readers to choose between doing something about it and going on putting up with it.
Sums that do not add up
The figures in the first report do not quite add up. At no less than $10 an acre, 2,000 acres would have cost at least $20,000, well above the $16,834.56 the column gave. Either there was less land than reported, some of it sold below $10, or the numbers were rounded.
The timing is uncertain too. The column spoke of the land as already bought. But as the Lusk family page sets out, the federal project to acquire land in and beside the reservation had been approved by July 1935, and owners’ options were being closed and paid from November 1936 on. What the paper reported in 1935 may have been options or agreements still waiting to close. Exactly where the tracts were, and which now lie inside the boundary, is not known. Perry Lusk’s name is not on the list; his family recalls that his West Fork ranch passed to the United States later, in the spring of 1939.
The land had a longer history with the reservation line. How the 1898 agreement drew that line is told in The reservation next door, and the dividing of the Bannock Creek lands in When the Bannock Creek lands were allotted. The same years brought the dispute over Arbon’s wheat road across the reservation, and the Pauline and West Fork page tells of the country where several of the sellers lived. The boundary they sold against in 1935 runs across the north end of the valley still.
Sources
- Pocatello Tribune, November 12, 1935, page 4
- Pocatello Tribune, November 13, 1935, page 4
- American Falls Press, March 29, 1917, page 7
- American Falls Press, June 5, 1917, page 2
- American Falls Press, July 10, 1917, page 8
- American Falls Press, March 6, 1924, page 5
- American Falls Press, August 6, 1925, page 3
- Deseret News, January 27, 1943, page 14
- Homestead patent to Charles E. Bolingbroke, October 19, 1908 (IDIDAA 005117)
- Homestead patent to John Bishoff, May 8, 1913 (IDBL 0004472)
- Cash patent to Thomas D. Price, June 11, 1913 (IDBL 0013563)
- Homestead patent to Thomas D. Price, October 31, 1914 (IDBL 0005795)
- Homestead patent to Thomas D. Price, April 25, 1924 (IDBL 0032345)
- Homestead patent to Belton Gooch, June 30, 1919 (IDBL 0024072)
- Homestead patent to H. Edmund Gooch, June 10, 1922 (IDBL 0030458)
- Stock-raising homestead patent to Asael P. Condit, January 12, 1940 (IDBL 0045381)