By the third week of September 1959, the men building State Highway 38 through Arbon Valley could see the end of a job that had run for 43 miles. Robert B. Christensen, the state’s district engineer for southeast Idaho, told the Idaho Sunday Journal that the work ranked as “one of the longest projects in Idaho road building history.” The paper ran his news on its editorial page on Sunday, September 20, under the headline “Arbon Highway Nearly Finished.”
The road began at the summit of the Mink Creek road, southeast of Pocatello, and ran south down into the valley. Christensen said the contract had been split into two sections. The first was all but done, and he expected the second to be finished in a week or ten days. Once the road met the required standard, he said, Power and Oneida counties would take it over. It lay in both: the Buist country at the south end of the valley is in Oneida County, and the rest of the valley is in Power. He did not say why the road was to pass to the counties, and the short item gave no cost, did not describe the new surface and did not name the contractors who built it.
The highway was the largest piece of a few years in which the roads into and through the valley were oiled one stretch at a time.
The Pauline road
The first word came out of American Falls in September 1957. The Power County commissioners, fixing the year’s tax levies, set the Arbon school district’s at 1.50 mills. In the same sitting they let a contract to the Holmes Construction Co. of Heyburn for oiling “the Pauline road.” The Journal printed the brief report on September 15 without saying which stretch was meant, how long it ran or what the oiling cost. It may have been part of the Bannock Creek road north from Pauline, but the paper never says, and no report found shows whether Holmes finished the work that year. By March 1961 the Bannock Creek road was hard-surfaced: when a pilot was killed near Bannock Peak that month, the Salt Lake Tribune put the wreck roughly five miles northwest of Pauline and a mile or so from “the paved Bannock Creek road.” The country at that end of the valley is described in Pauline and West Fork.
Toward Hawkins
In the summer of 1958 Bannock County, to the east, was at work on a road of its own. The Virginia–Hawkins road was to run nine miles from U.S. Highway 91-191 to the Hawkins Reservoir. Seven of those miles were already being built with federal help, and the last 2½ had been held up by money and right of way. On July 6 the Journal reported that the county would call for bids on that final stretch around July 15. The county was putting up $3,500, and Commissioner James A. Abbott said the $40,000 in federal matching money was now secured. The federal aid program counted it a farm-to-market road, meant for farms in the Hawkins basin and in “part of the Arbon Valley.” Abbott planned to gravel it that year and have the county oil it in 1959.
A year-round road to town
When the Mink Creek work was done, the Pocatello Chamber of Commerce claimed a share of the credit. Its annual report, summed up in the Idaho State Journal’s Progress Edition of February 29, 1960, listed the finished, oiled road from Mink Creek into Arbon Valley among the good things of 1959. The Chamber said the result owed something to its agriculture and highway committees working together, and that the road “opens up the upper valley year around,” giving valley families a better way to Pocatello than they had ever had. The papers say nothing more of what the change meant to the people who drove it.
The valley remembers the same year. The site’s history of Buist says the gravel road was first oiled about 1959, from Holbrook north up the valley as far as the Crystal turnoff. The Chamber’s report and the Buist history most likely describe the two ends of a single 1959 job, though neither one says so. Which contractor oiled Highway 38 is not recorded in the reports found, and neither is the date the highway actually went to the counties. When floods cut off Arbon Valley in March 1962 and Rattlesnake Creek washed a break in the road, it was still being called State Highway 38.
The Hawkins road accepted
Bannock County did not take over the Virginia–Hawkins road until 1961. On September 14 that year the Journal reported that the county would formally accept nine miles of it the following day, once Abbott and County Engineer Vern Powell had looked it over. The oiling and seal coat had gone to Mountain States Construction Co. of Pocatello. The papers do not make clear whether the oil went down in 1959, as first planned, or only shortly before the acceptance. The commissioners said farmers hauling produce to Downey, Virginia and Arimo would have an easier trip, and that it would also serve Crystal and Arbon Valley, where much of the area’s grain was grown. Commissioner Emmette Spraker said federal funds paid 62 per cent of the cost and the county the other 38.
The site weighs the rival claims for the first oiled road to reach the valley. Earlier fights over the way to market are told in mail, grain and the Mink Creek road and Arbon’s wheat road across the reservation. By the fall of 1961, the grain from the valley could go out to market on oil.