While a plane circled and men on horseback rode the hills, the man they were looking for was riding a bus home to Fort Hall.
Tom Leach, a sheepherder in his seventies, had gone out with his friend James Cornelison, another Fort Hall man, to prospect on a mining claim Cornelison held in the country around Bannock Peak, at the north end of Arbon Valley. The peak stands roughly five miles northwest of Pauline, as the site’s account of a 1961 plane crash places it, and the history of Pauline and West Fork describes that end of the valley. Somewhere up there the clutch went out on their pickup, and the two were stuck. On Wednesday, September 2, 1970, Leach left the truck and started walking for Rockland, over in the neighboring valley to the west.
Neither man came home that day. On Wednesday night Helen Shepard, a relative of Cornelison’s, reported them missing. Power County deputies headed out in the dark, and volunteers from Bannock County Search and Rescue drove out to work alongside them. Before dawn Thursday the searchers reached the disabled pickup and found Cornelison waiting there. He joined the hunt for his partner.
A day in the hills
Since Leach had set out for Rockland, that was the direction the search took on Thursday. About eight Search and Rescue volunteers were in it, most of them covering the ground in four-wheel-drive rigs while two who were pilots flew overhead. C. M. Windham, special officer for the Bureau of Indian Affairs, said the bureau’s range department was sending three riders. The papers do not say why the bureau joined in beyond the fact that both men lived at Fort Hall.
The Bannock County Mounted Sheriff’s Posse rode out with eleven members. Jim Lupher, its president, went himself and afterward gave the names of those who searched with him: George Ellis, Murray Green, Don Mecham, Randall Adams, T. B. Porter, Doug Trego, Bill McAughey, Dean Hunter, Neal Freckleton and Karen Bird. The plane never spotted Leach.
He found his own way
That was because he was no longer out there. Leach had kept walking until he reached Rockland. There he got a lift to Blackfoot, and from Blackfoot he caught a bus to Fort Hall, reaching his home on the townsite Thursday night. When word came that he was safe, the searchers came in after about a day in the hills. The Journal told the story on Thursday, September 3, and its ending the next day.
The two reports leave some things out. They do not say just where Cornelison’s claim lay, what he hoped to find on it, or how many miles Leach covered on foot before Rockland. They also differ on Cornelison’s age: Thursday’s paper put both men in their seventies, while Friday’s said he was 82. Neither man appears anywhere else in the papers searched for this site, and nothing ties either to a valley family.
Bannock Peak has its own place in the valley’s stories, from an auto trip around the peak in 1911 to that fatal crash in 1961. And the valley had searched for a lost walker once before, in 1954, when a young man headed toward the mountains, as told in the search for Gene Bailey. This time the lost man found his own way out.